Ashley_Rose
2020
2017
Anyone who looks at my games played will notice I like niche stuff made by aeutors and boy howdy, this is the best of the best. Like any of those games you need to be down for 'one of those' but this game did something no other like it had, it completely enraptured me and then ended in such a way where I felt like it was definitively over and I felt no need to come back. No stringing me along with the promise of unending content or microtransactions, it said what it wanted to say and definitively gave you a point to stop.
2015
2018
( I am only judging this on story as I played through this long after it was relevant content) A very safe traditional fantasy story that shines with likable characters and excellent music. Manages to avoid my most constant frustration with FF14's writing, which is threatening to do something interesting but then deciding not to. Mind you, it does this by never taking any big swings, but a simple story told well is fine thing in my book.
Looking back at this it is shocking how starkly different I feel about these characters now vs. then. Half the cast was insufferable and the other bland with a meandering story. It is a testament to the improving writing of the expansions that I genuinely like all the Scions but woof it takes a bit to get there.
2016