It's good until the free roam ends

What a mess of an open world. When you're done with it / breaking it, you still have the entire main questline to go through. No thanks

The fact that I can criticize the game for that is itself an achievement considering its team of three people, but oh my is that game overly padded with content

This game has no flaws to speak of, but it lacks the "oompf" that makes an all-time classic.

Die in a fire you piece of fucking shit

Unforgettable art direction and creative use of the Mario universe

Play this on a CRT TV when the Internet is out

I still use the cups password to this day

Should have left us hanging for 20 more years if this is what you were going to do with it

Why do you people hate it so much

Drop the always online BS and we have a serious contender for the GOAT