WuPac
2009
In its original state, definitely the worst SoulsBorne game, but still very much worth playing if you can't get your hands on a PS5. The prototype for all the greatness to come. World Tendency is awful even when you are able to finally understand it, and that's just one of many crazy negative quirks in the game that From Software thankfully learned from.
2017
It took me a long time to get into it for some reason - In my first few sessions I considered dropping it completely. But once I did get into it I was enthralled. Aloy as a character, the story, and the dialogue are all nothing special. But the gameplay, world, and enemies are all fantastic and incredibly unique and original. The human enemies are pretty lame. Lance Reddick's character is the highlight of the story.
2015
Definitely has lower replayability than most narrative choices games, but also a lot more interesting and cool than most of them. I surprisingly actually really enjoyed the plot and the characters - Going from hating the douchey annoying teens you play as to really rooting for and caring about what happens to them is a nice feeling.
2009
2016