I was surprised how short this DLC is and kinda disappointed. I liked Joshua Graham a lot and how both endings have their ups and downs but this DLC could’ve benefited from atleast three more hours of content and some mission variety. All in all, it’s pretty decent and has its moments but still is pretty weak compared to the main game and doesn’t offer that much interesting content like I was hoping it would do.

I don't know why this game is this good but it just is. Only reason why it's not a 5/5 is because of Atlantica.

Solid game but definetly hasn’t aged that well compared to other Rockstar titles around that time. Mission variety is basically nonexistent and most of the missions are the usual Rockstar slop: ride with a NPC for a couple of minutes while going to a destination, kill the bad guys, victory. Other than that every other aspect is good/great except the stranger missions.