While it's still one of the best, the amount of bugs and unfinished content at launch were extremely detrimental to my first experience(s) with it as a kid. Constant crashing. I played it a bit on PC with mods, but never finished.
Absolutely beautiful experience. If ot weren't for a couple slightly obtuse clues it would probably be perfect. Haven't played it with the DLC yet, so maybe it is perfect by now.
A solid Mario game with not much else going for it. In a series known for innovating on the same formula for 40 years, this just doesn't do anything special.
BotW but better. Sadly, it came out after BotW, so we've already seen a large part of what it has to offer. If BotW didn't exist this would be a strong 4, if not a 5.