Atmosphere: 9/10
Guns: 7/10
Graphics: 9/10
Story: 6/10
Controls/Engine: 10/10
Sounds and Music: 7/10 (there is not really music):
Gameplay: 8/10
Characters: 5/10 (I hate Alyx)
(played 25 hours - completed all achievements)

Atmosphere: 7/10
Gameplay: 9/10 (Fun riddles)
Story: 8/10
Controls/Engine: 9/10
Sounds and Music: 7/10
Graphics: 6/10
(played 14 hours - completed all achievements)

Gameplay 7/10 (it's fun but repetitive)
Atmosphere 7/10
Combat/Guns: 8/10
Multiplayer: 7/10 (but it's kinda dead)
Controls/Movement: 8/10
Graphics: 7/10
Story: 6/10
Sounds/Music: 7/10
(played 68 hours - completed all achievements)

Gameplay: 8/10 (Killing bad people and hunting)
Controls/Movement: 8/10
Sounds/Music: 6/10
Story: 6/10
Combat/Guns: 8/10
Atmosphere: 7/10
Graphics: 7/10
Characters: 6/10 (Liked villains and Main char development)
World Design: 7/10 (Much Jungle)
(Played 40 hours - Completed on 100%)

Gameplay: 8/10
Controls/Movement: 9/10 (bhopping kinda possible)
Sounds/Music: 10/10 (nice radio music)
Story: 9/10
Combat/Guns: 7/10
Atmosphere: 9/10
Graphics: 7/10
Characters: 8/10
World Design: 8/10
(Played 170 hours - completed all Achievements)

Gameplay: 7/10 (gets repetitive after a while)
Controls/Movement: 8/10
Sounds/Music: 8/10
Story: 7/10
Combat/Guns: 8/10 (better than in 3 but bad hit feedback)
Atmosphere: 7/10
Graphics: 8/10
Characters: 9/10 (Good villains)
World Design: 8/10 (Forest)
(Played 65 hours - Completed on Hard + New game+)

I respect what the game did to the game industry
but it was not fun playing it.

Half Life 2 way better
(played 11 hours)

Gameplay: 9/10
Controls/Movement: 9/10 (dodge roll)
Sounds/Music: 8/10
Story: 10/10
Combat/Weapons: 9/10
Atmosphere: 10/10
Graphics: 9/10
Characters: 10/10 (perfect npcs imo)
World Design: 10/10 (nice world connection and shortcuts)
criticism:
- I hate the random kick move
- some Boss Arenas are trash
- Bosses are too easy in general, but the walk from the bonfires are way too long
- Bed of Chaos and Lost Izalith = bad

(played 140h - replayed x6 times - Completed all achievements)