Phantom0
1998
2001
1998
2002
2013
1998
Gonna be honest, I was shocked at how fun I found this on a recent replay. For years I've thought of Sonic Adventure as a game that aged horribly, and yeah things like the cutscene animation and Amy and Big's stories do drag the game down, but I was surprised at just how fun the majority of the game is, with Sonic and Gamma's stories being particular highlights.
Horrendous pacing and a story that's kinda all over the place. Definitely an improvement over the original game in terms of general story quality and characters. That said, I feel it's also just not a very good remake in terms of improving what worked about the original (deciding instead to just throw out almost everything). It's not terrible or anything, just not very good.