Bad platforming, generic story, mediocre gunplay, repetitive level and encounter design, annoyingly on rails. But the graphics were good in 2009 or something.

A game that I respect more than I actually enjoy. I understand it's influence and I love some of the other content this universe has produced (Remake is incredible). But man this game has been completely decimated by the passage of time. Most of the time, when I play an seminal classic, I find that they've aged well and are fun even in the context of modern gaming (SOTN is an example of a game that came out the same year and hasn't aged a day), but FF7 is unfortunately an exception for me. The gameplay is too slow and easy, the movement feels awkward, the visuals and presentation are really unappealing (this is coming from someone who loves plenty of uglier games), and the UI and menus are simply awful.

Despite my mixed feelings on this game, it's very easy to see why it's such a beloved classic. The worldbuilding, story, music, variety, and characters are all good even today. While I think Square Enix's take on remaking this game has had an excellent start and much more ambitious than anyone could have imagined. I do hope that one day we get another take of this game that sticks closer to the original vision while smoothing out the rough edges I mentioned, since Remake is so fundamentally different from the original experience.

Fantastic DLC that surprisingly wasn't too difficult to jump back in given that I haven't played in years now. If I have any gripe it's that I still think there's a tad too much rng going on in these fights, but nothing here was as annoying as the dragon from the base game.

Level design seemed like a step up from what I played (not a high bar given how terrible this aspect was in the first game). But this retains the same problems with the moment to moment movement and combat feel that the first game had. For a game about the lightsaber fantasy it simply just does not feel good to play and swing your lightsaber around. There's too many good games out there and I know I'm probably wasting my time given how I've felt about this series so far so I dropped it like 8 hours in.

Soma Cruz is the most dripped out character in gaming

What if we took Xenoblade's party, kept only two of them, and replaced the rest of the party with two Nopon that are just as annoying as Riki but don't have any of his good traits? Oh and the two Nopon are going to have the exact same movesets as the characters from the base game you actually like, just to rub it in more.

The combat and music are still great, but when a JRPG starts tempting me to skip cutscenes you know something is off.

Rebirth is gonna be so fucking good

I mean, it's scientifically proven to reduce depression symptoms for a reason

Conceptually one of the most interesting puzzle games I've ever played but it doesn't feel like it's ideas are fully fleshed out. Also wish it had more of a narrative hook.

I've warmed up to this game a lot over the years. Even if the single player campaign itself isn't amongst the series' best I have to give it additional points for streamlining the multiplayer experience and also having one of the most fun eras of competitive Pokemon. Also, Mega evolutions are an absolutely genius idea and easily the best gimmick in the series.

This is my "you had to be there" game.

I was forced to play this game because I lost a bet

With Dishonored, Arkane dares to ask the age old question:

"What if Bioshock was actually good?"

If this game was just the Herald of Darkness level it would still be one of the best experiences of 2023.

Nintendo, this remake is awesome, but please make/publish new Mario RPGs where we have non-toad NPCs again 😭😭😭