Decent fun. Pretty impressive given that it was one of the first rhythm games. I like the concept behind the freestyling mechanic but I think it could've used more guidance to see how to actually do it properly beyond just experimentation

the atmosphere in this game is incredibly good and the rest of it is very fun

This game is the perfect example of quality over quantity. The whole thing takes place in one small town and stars a small cast of only 4 characters from start to finish, but by the end of the game you are incredibly attached to Crossbell and the SSS. I look forward to going back when Geofront finishes their translation of Azure.

i don't remember a single thing about this game

this game has some incredibly high peaks and cool atmosphere but man some of the fights do be dogshit

Super fun and charming game, only reason it isn't a 10/10 is because there were too many fabric missions

the game making clown noises at you every time you die is a perfect summary, i think

since the devs made the groundbreaking decision of literally just removing the shitty gameplay i can give this game's story the rating it deserves

I have a lot more thoughts about this game than I do about most Metroidvanias, so that's worth something already.
I find it interesting that the exploration is not what is the best part of the game, but instead it's atmosphere. Rather than feeling like an adventure through an alien planet, this game almost has the atmosphere of a survival horror game. There is an active threat in this area that is thinking and planning as much (if not more) than you are, and it knows this environment better than you do. You're not running around for fun, you're running around to stop the X from taking over/destroying the entire ship. This is way more engaging to me, personally, though I will admit I'm not super into Metroidvanias in general.
Another part I like is how the game constantly keeps you on your toes. Just when you think the game is falling into a rhythm, the elevator stops while you're in it, or you fall into a room with SA-X.
I also like the way that the exploration actively adds to the "going rogue" atmosphere. At the start you're following orders and being pointed to the next spot on the map, but as time goes on you have to start improvising routes, finding spots that aren't marked on the map, cutting through secret passages that get you between sectors without using the elevators, and that's to say nothing of all the times you indirectly go against orders just to go back to old areas and get items.
I do think the game has some flaws, mainly in terms of how much the exploration side of the Metroidvania gets sacrificed. The game feels incredibly linear at times, and there were moments when I wanted to explore and felt that there were arbitrary restrictions in place to keep me on the rails. For every really tense moment, there has to be a bunch of obstacle setting and door sealing to make sure the player goes on the route to actually see it as intended.
It's worth noting that Metroid Prime came out a single day before this game, meaning they were being developed at the same time. Prime also had storytelling, but its was different in that all of it was told through scannable things, such as walls or computers. This is a story that lets the player read it at their leisure, and if they don't want that, they don't have to read it at all. In hindsight, I think this type of storytelling lends itself better to the metroidvania playstyle, but I still admit that Fusion's more linear storytelling did provide for a lot of more memorable moments.

It's fun and all but there's so much backtracking in this game, it's unreal. I'm not just talking about chapter 7. It feels like every chapter has some unnecessary walking to A and B and back to A and maybe even back to B after that, especially if you want badges. People also act like this game has a way better plot than other mario RPGs. It doesn't? The villains aren't characterized at all. This is one of those games that a ton of people say is the best in the world despite not having played it in 10 years. It has soul, but not much substance.

i just don't like the scanning thing cause it feels like it makes the exploration less fun, the spider ball is ass with areas this big (oh boy can't wait to crawl along the ceiling and walls of this room for 5 minutes JUST IN CASE there's a secret), and all the focus on parrying just makes all other, faster parts of combat less satisfying

I mean it's fun enough but I don't think I'd consider this anything close to a Metroidvania. It feels like I can't go more than 10 minutes without having something get sealed off behind me. I never got lost, but I never felt like I was given a chance to navigate either. Also the EMMIs often felt more annoying than scary, which took away from the appeal of having a common enemy to be scared of.

This review contains spoilers

This is probably my favorite thing Toby Fox has made so far. Undertale and Deltarune Ch 1, I felt that he was really good at writing comedy but was less consistent with writing more serious, thought provoking content. I think that changed with this game.
Having a party of characters is so good. He skillfully uses splits in the party to help showcase different dynamics between the characters and to keep things fresh. The plot is definitely carried by its characters for now, but I'm okay with that.
Gameplay has also improved. I think the spare percentage system instead of a binary spare/no spare thing is great.
Update: I played through Snowgrave and it was raw as FUCK compared to the genocide route of UT

The mixing of copy abilities is very fun and I wish the series did it more often, but everything else, especially the level design and movement, leaves a lot to be desired.