I wasn't expecting this to be as good as it was. This was a love letter to all of the previous Mario games.

Nothing will ever top this.

Not only is this very easily my favorite Mario sidescroller, this is probably in contention for my favorite sidescroller ever.

Respect for it starting it all, but judging it alone, it does not stand up to later games.

I wish I loved this one more, as it seems to be a crowd favorite. The other 3D Mario games were better.

The least memorable Kart game.

I remember my mom somehow, inexplicably knew all of the secrets to this game and showed us as kids.

This game was weird and has a weird backstory

I played this a ton as a kid. My sister and I will still break it out from time to time.

It was fine as a remake. The multiplayer mode was surprisingly fun.

Mario Kart peaked on the GameCube.

Remake this, you cowards!

Fun, but I didn't play it for too long before getting bored.

The minigames were fantastic, but the boards were mostly uninteresting.

I grew up on this game, and still break it out with my sister every now and then.

As far as on the N64 Parties go, this was definitely the least impressive.

Soccer, meh

Good, but lesser to it's immediate successor in every way.

Favorite of the Parties. I've spent many, many nights laughing with friends with this game. Amazing games, great boards, fun gimmicks, and ran great on the GameCube.

Definitely the least memorable of all the Parties.

Never really got too into the Mario sports games. This is the one exception, for some reason it grabbed onto me as a kid. I never owned it, but I rented it from Blockbuster at least a dozen times and played it for hours on end.