My GOTY picks: 1986-2020

Ever since the 80s, I've always been about 5 years behind the curve on the GOTY debate. For the most part, I'd rather be patient and scoop up all the best stuff for mega-cheap, long after all the DLC & patching is done and the critical dust has settled.

That said, it's fun that Backloggd makes it easy to just sort your played list by year and pick out your faves in retrospect. So here's all my current GOTY picks, if I had to look back and choose them all today.

(In other words, for this list I'mma just go off Backloggd's release dates instead of trying to recall the actual years that I played all these.)

Signs of the Sojourner
Signs of the Sojourner
{2020} A story about being away for so long that you forget even how to talk to your old friends and family hit pretty hard in 2020
The Walking Dead: The Telltale Definitive Series
The Walking Dead: The Telltale Definitive Series
{2019} They had to bring an entire studio back from the dead to finish this, and it was worth it
Return of the Obra Dinn
Return of the Obra Dinn
{2018} There's never been another game like this but I want there to be 100 more
The Long Dark
The Long Dark
{2017} Rolls up all my favorite parts of the survival-crafting genre into one all-pervasive MEGA MOOD
Overwatch
Overwatch
{2016} Simply the best thing to ever happen to competitive online shooters
Agar.io
Agar.io
{2015} a minimalist masterpiece
Crypt of the NecroDancer
Crypt of the NecroDancer
{2014} Funky AND Fresh
The Wolf Among Us
The Wolf Among Us
{2013} That year when it seemed like Telltale might replace television, and I was all for it
Mass Effect 3
Mass Effect 3
{2012} The ME3 Defender has entered the chat
Minecraft
Minecraft
{2011} Didn't get great until mods years later but heck yeah punch a tree
Mass Effect 2
Mass Effect 2
{2010} They continued my favorite action sci-fi story of all-time and then also made the guns more fun to shoot. HELL YEA VIDEOGAMES!
Assassin's Creed II
Assassin's Creed II
{2009} speaking of parkour: what if that but also medieval churches and murder?
Mirror's Edge
Mirror's Edge
{2008} before The Office made parkour a joke, let's all be thankful that Mirror's Edge was there to make it look like the coolest shit possible
Mass Effect
Mass Effect
{2007} '07 was a legendarily good year for games, but this one's still the goodest
The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion
The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion
{2006} honestly I would go outside more if there were nirnroots irl
Psychonauts
Psychonauts
{2005} I AM THE MILK MAN MY MILK IS DELICIOUS
Myst IV: Revelation
Myst IV: Revelation
{2004} Half-Life 2, KOTOR 2, and Halo 2 can all eat it, this was my most-beloved sequel of the year
Pac-Man Vs.
Pac-Man Vs.
{2003} There have been few game ideas as good as "it's pac-man but the ghosts are controlled by your asshole friends"
Unreal Tournament 2003
Unreal Tournament 2003
{2002} U! T! 2! K! 3! The last great zany LAN game, back before shooters had to be sweaty and balanced due to "esports"
Final Fantasy X
Final Fantasy X
{2001} Every other FF would be better if it had FFX's breezy beach-episode tone, and also its combat system (fight me)
Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2
Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2
{2000} CANT STOP GUERRILLA RADIO TURN THAT SHHT UP
Planescape: Torment
Planescape: Torment
{1999} Games are art and also literature
Half-Life
Half-Life
{1998} Classic Deathmatch specifically, on the map Gasworks, on a 6-port LAN, for 18 consecutive hours
Fallout
Fallout
{1997} Wrote the blueprint for western turn-based RPGs
Super Mario 64
Super Mario 64
{1996} Looking back I still like Mario 3 more, but this was goddamn revelatory when it came out
Chrono Trigger
Chrono Trigger
{1995} Everyone knows they shoulda made 15 of these instead
Star Wars: TIE Fighter
Star Wars: TIE Fighter
{1994} Blew my tiny nerd mind
Myst
Myst
{1993} Basically bought a PC for this and X-Wing, have not been outside since
Street Fighter II: Champion Edition
Street Fighter II: Champion Edition
{1992} Woof, I like SF alright but kind of a tough year for releases (though iirc this is the actual year that Link to the Past was released in the US)
The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past
The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past
{1991} Yeah I know, I said I never got a SNES, but of course I've played ports of this, and it's legendary
StarTropics
StarTropics
{1990} The Zelda for cool kids
River City Ransom
River City Ransom
{1989} It took like 20 years for there to be a better beat-em-up than this
Super Mario Bros. 3
Super Mario Bros. 3
{1988} Maybe it's just cuz I never got a SNES, but this is the all-time peak of the Mario mountain for me
NetHack
NetHack
{1987} If you want to impress me beat a real roguelike, kiddos
Fantasy Zone
Fantasy Zone
{1986} People forget that Resogun is just a better-looking-but-less-fun version of Fantasy Zone

2 Comments


2 years ago

If you're looking for games like Return of the Obra Dinn, you might enjoy the first Echo Night game, they got similarities iirc

2 years ago

@FrozenRoy: whoa, PS1-era From Soft? I'd never heard of it, wishlisting that for sure. I didn't own a PS1 back in the day and certainly wouldn't have been a cool enough kid to be playing something like Echo Night. :)


Last updated: