Tied with MP and MM
FES > P3P
Portable is still worth playing for the Female route, which acts as a very nice what if scenario to P3 that compliments the Male route well.

Tied with P3 and MM

Tied with P3 and MP
Proxy entries for both MM64 and 3D, I believe both have things that they uniquely do well and both are worth a run through.

Order is KH1 > 2 > GBA CoM > ReCOM > 358/2 > DDD > BBS = Remind > 3 > Coded overall in terms of games.
I didn't mean the movies for 358 or coded

MAIDEN IN BLACK I KNEEL
PS3 > PS5, voice acting and music alone is significantly better

Beacause translation is the best way to experience the game, ideally on the PSX version if possible.

Includes Rebirth

JP Soundtrack, not US
TELEPORTATION YEAAAAAAAAH ZA BA DOO BAP BAP

2 > 3 > 1=4

Love the original art style but definitive is really the best way to experience the game, and the new art works extremely well.

MGS2 > 1 > 4 > 3 > MG2 = PW = Acid > PO > MG1
Have not played Ghost Babel or Acid 2. All of these are really close with the exception of 2, which is my personal favorite

Neutral > both others

Better SADX is the way to go, imo.
SA1 holds a lot of nostalgia for me (first game I ever owned alongside wind waker), and the narrative style of
separate stories connected by an overarching thread greatly influenced my personal tastes.

DX makes significant enough improvements that I prefer it over vanilla SF at this point

The framerate is abysmal but the game slaps

Includes OG Gestalt
Ending D > Ending E, imo, but both work really well
The only song that's worse in 1.22 is just shadowlord, every other track is just as good if not better

I prefer 3D over 64, as I believe it is a substantial upgrade over the original, although the original holds a large place in my heart still.

1 > 2 & ODST > 3 > Reach > 4

1 > 3 > 2

LADY MARIA I KNEEL
Old hunters included

Never have assless chap's looked so manly

EMERALD HERALD I KNEEL
There's enough differences between the two that I like both versions, but I prefer Scholar overall.

DS > Switch in terms of gameplay, Original > Remix for soundtrack

Proxy entry for both White and White 2, ranking is W2 > W though

PS2 > HD
Face models on PS2 are so fantastic that their stilted animations and overall awkward appearance in HD just completely ruins the experience for me

GYWNDOLIN I KNEEL
I slightly prefer PTDE, but Remastered is perfectly fine

Proxy entry for the entirety of .hack//IMOQ rather than just being infection

I prefer 3DS for portability but PS2 undub is the best experience

From a pure gameplay perspective automata absolutely blows this game out of the park, but I just find myself drawn to the world, characters, and overall narrative of DOD1 so much more than automata that it becomes hard to really view it objectively whatsoever

Includes Suguri

PC release is the best way to play nowadays

DS > Snes, imo
PC is ideal with fixes, but I still prefer DS

I really love the leave ending but in water is good too

I prefer PS1, but all versions are fine tbh

I AM THE BONE OF MY SWORD
STEEL IS MY BODY AND FIRE IS MY BLOOD
I HAVE CREATED OVER A THOUSAND BLADES

Ranking is 3 > 6 > 1=2 > 5=4
I actually don't dislike any of the games so these are fairly close. 4 is probably the weakest following up 3, but otherwise its a mostly alright game.
Preferred Versions are: 3 = Any (White's more of a challenge), 4 = Blue Moon, 5 = Any (DS best version if applicable) 6 = Falzar

MONKEY

Includes AC4

I really, really love the endgame

Both versions of the game are fantastic but the original will always hold a special place in my heart.

Its twin peaks the game, of course I love it

I just really like rhythm games

JP release, us release removes all of the story and cutscenes. The ending alone changed my entire perception of the game, absolutely love the story

PS2 > PC
Absolutely insane how well this game holds up graphically

Proxy Entry for the whole series.
Personal ranking is: 3U > P3rd > GU=4U=Rise > MHFU > MHF > World

holy sHIIIIIIT the foreshadowing oh my god
Proxy entry for the whole series as well, ranking is Saga > Zwei > 1=Orta

Includes EP

Its twin peaks the game II, of course I love it

PS3 > PC

SOTC > Ico, but both are very close. I think both games should be looked at together as ICO and SOTC both are thematically linked, and SOTC in particular acts as a foil to many of ICO's plot elements.

The atmosphere is really just that good

EoV was the first Etrian I played and really got into, hence its higher score than others.

Radical Dreamers on PC with fixes is the best way to play CC.

A gunpla fan's wet dream, absolutely filled to the brim with insane customization and a decently fun gameplay loop

The absolute poster child of “how you do a remake”, exclusively enhancing the original in every single way while keeping its core intact